Note: Since our ‘promotion’ to PC, my reviews have been more focused on the nuances of the new level, and I have not captured much info on the other levels. Looking for volunteers interested in helping me remedy that by adding grade level review info the the feis review. Thanks.
The North Coast Feis was held on February 1st, 2014 at the IX Center in Cleveland, OH.
Venue – The IX Center was OK as a feis venue. The PC/OC area was in the ballroom on the main level and was a good size room, but not adequate for the amount of people needing to be in there.
Camping was not sufficient and there was lots of camping in the viewer seating. Many areas were marked ‘no camping’ but they were full of campers, and that caused some flow issues for people trying to get from the front to the back of the room.
There were 3 stages labeled G – I, for PC and OC dancers. Stage sizes appeared to be about 20 x 24 and were small for the level of dancers performing on them. The stages were extremely slippery and there were lots of falls. The feis team mopped often but it did not help.
There was pretty good separation between the stages, but music could be heard from neighboring stages. It did not seem to impact the dancers much though.
Seating was not adequate for the viewers, but was probably all they could put in considering room size. The feis committee attempted to leave adequate room for people to move around (I refer back to the camping in the no camping area comment), but it really did not work out.
Parking was good, not all ‘close’, but plentiful. It was a bit pricey at $8. The weather was not great on that day but there was a large covered drop off area in front of the venuw.
Venue Score: 6.5
Judges – With the Girl Child having 3 dances, and dancing on 3 separate stages, and because PC dancers have 3 judges per stage, none of whom rotated to another stage, I have no complaints on the judging.
I actually thought it was an excellent opportunity for the dancers, performing in front of 9 different judges for the feis. With 9 judges, comments were more well rounded than the typical 2 or 3 judges that you ‘might’ get at a grade level.
Judge Score: 10
Music -Each stage had its own musician and I did not hear any complaints about music.
Musician Score: 9.5
Food – Standard convention center food, hamburgers, cheesebugers, pretzels, pizza, wraps and salads, a coffee stand, various drink booths and beer. Food quality was OK but not worth the price. It was about what you expect for a convention center.
Food Score: 6.5
Vendors – George, the shoe guy, and Betsy, his daughter(who also responds to ‘George’s Daughter’ btw), the feis t-shirt table, wig ladies, a jewelry booth, an Irish wool and linens vendor, and the photographer. You can see all the vendors at the the feis site under Vendors.
Vendor Score: 7.5
Results – Results are different at Champ level, as some of you know. Results for all dances are completed, top 3 in each dance determined, and then the overall top half from the entire comp are determined. When they are ready, the dancers are gathered and awards presented.
I can understand where it would take time to do this, but timeliness was only one of the issues I felt the results had. It took approximately 1.5 to 2 hours from completion of TGCs last dance to presentation of her awards. I felt that was a little long, granted, I have never tallied a PC comp so that might be normal.
Results were presented in an area on the lower level that would have been fine if comps had been done one at a time. Thing is, they waited until somewhere around 5 comps were ready before presenting the awards.
Picture if you will, 5 comps of dancers with 10 – 20 dancers each, the parents and friends for all those dancers, and dance bags and zucas for some of them, crammed into an area not fit for that many people. It was difficult for dancers to get to the presentation area when called, and for spectators to see, and picture taking was next to impossible. Not planned well at all. I feel simply doing them one comp at a time would have helped tremendously.
Results Score: 3.5
Feis Flow – Flow was not bad considering the number of dancers, TGC had three dances on three separate stages, with about 20 dancers in the comp and she was finished in roughly 2.5 hours. Since this is only the second PC feis we have attended, I really do not have a standard to judge it by, but I thought that was pretty good.
Feis Flow Score: 8
Two part scoring with a Feis Score consisting of Judging, Music, Results and Flow, and then the overall consisting of everything.
Feis Score: 7.75 – Not bad, but was really helped by judges and music, which by the nature of the champ level will probably score higher by default (gotta think about that for future reviews).
And the WTF Rating – a WTF Rating is 7.35
What Say You?Sorry, there are no polls available at the moment.
This was our first time at NCF. As the mom of a grade level dancer, I have a few thoughts (as I usually do. lol!).
There was a slightly unfortunate issue with Stage F (which is where my dancer was mainly scheduled to dance): it was missing a judge and a musician. I heard that the judge was stuck in Chicago, but never did hear about the musician. The communication about this was pretty much word-of-mouth and not everyone got the word. Understandably, there were some seriously irritated parents and dancers as dancers were shuffled from stage to stage. The teen volunteers at stage F were amazing. They kept their cool, and smiles, even when people were flat out yelling in their faces, and did an extraordinary job of making sure every dancer was present before any dance scheduled for Stage F began (regardless of where the dance had been transferred to). I can’t commend them enough. Those in charge….I can’t commend so much. Considering that I received an email seemingly every 3 minutes about PC/OC results, it is clear they had the ability to communicate what was happening with stage F and could have saved so much frustration just by communicating the information throughout the day to ensure everyone got the word. It would have made for a much more relaxed experience for everyone, especially their volunteers.
The stages felt a little smallish for my dancer (who is U13) and those older, and even leggier, than she is. They were well cared for, though, and I didn’t see any slipping or falls. The judge rotation was great! Best we’ve encountered thus far. She got to dance for, and get feedback from, about 4 judges for 6 dances. And they all gave helpful feedback, smiled at the dancers, and despite all the frustrations they were very encouraging to the dancers. Can’t complain about that. :-). My dancer also really appreciated that there was a fantastic practice stage!
The musicians were great, mostly accordions, and there wasn’t any music blending together from stage to stage. The musician at stage E got pretty upset because people kept jumping over the barrier behind her and it was quite disruptive. Why they didn’t have the tensabarriers set up to allow a walk way between stages D & E was a mystery. Not only was it annoying that there was only 1 way to enter the grade level stages, it also seemed rather unsafe given the number of people. Had there been an emergency, it would have been a bad situation. Hopefully that will be rethought next year.
I felt the space was plenty roomy and there was a lot of camping available, don’t know why people weren’t using it. Dining tables were at a premium and people were camping at them! Tables were “claimed” with stuff and then left largely unoccupied and we had to eat on the floor. Hopefully that will be forbidden in the future.
For the most part, results were posted very pr0mptly. For whatever reason, however, my dancer’s last dance was not posted for 40 minutes. The vendors were all packing up, stages were being torn down, and there wasn’t much to do during the wait. It was very frustrating. Worth it though, as it was the 2nd place needed for my dancer to claim the title of “Novice” in all her dances. :-).
That’s the perspective of one grade level dancer’s mom……
Thanks! I also copied your comments over to the Grade Level review I just posted. :)
My dd dressed down at the grades level (I was running stage A) and my husband would page me just before her dance so that I could come up to watch her before heading back down into the trenches. :-/ It was a pretty good arrangement considering the lack of camping space upstairs, but obviously Something Needs To Be Done, especially in view that almost all of the ‘no camping’ areas had to be pressed into camping duty and it still didn’t accommodate everyone. Results *were* a pain in the posterior, and I’ll pass your review on to the people who set that up and see if there’s a more efficient way of handling it.
Thanks Lark, and sorry for the delayed response. Since I trust you, I don’t get notice when you post like new posters ;)
No probs. :-) How did TGC do? My dd had an OK day, middle of the pack.
We had a very long series of follow-up meetings after the feis was over, and the good news is that we are going to have a standard set of procedures to handle things like integrating refugee dancers and keeping the participants and parents informed in the event of troubles. I may have swayed everyone on the “let’s ALL do lunch at once” thing at the grades stages, but I may have to fight that battle again next year when they are setting the day’s schedule. :-P The bad news concerning the PC/OC stages is that there may not be any relief unless we can rent more of the IX center for less $$ than they are demanding. NCF is a break-even feis. Any “profits” get plowed back into the feis, and we genuinely did just break even this year, as we are going to be replacing several of the stages. The trouble with the NCF is that there are so many dance schools within spitting distance that it’s not just the parents who come with the dancers. Auntie Edna, Uncle Sean, Gran and Grandpa, assorted cousins and a few hangers-on of the ‘friend’ persuasion show up, too. This makes the venue very crowded (and leads to the seat-saving rudeness that we both abhor) and the immovable object “we can’t drop our champ cap!” folks has met the irresistible force of the greedy venue owners. There’s plenty of room at the IX center. If we could move the champ stages to the main floor and out of the ballroom, that would solve many problems. But the amount of money IX wants is well out of our budget, and they don’t seem interested in lowering the price, even though we are a non-profit (they claim we are getting a break already, which if true, makes the space breathtakingly expensive and not just holy crap! expensive). The tl;dr version: the champ stages are likely to remain overcrowded. I’ll keep you posted if anything changes.
Lark, thanks for the update. Would love to see if the comments make any impact on the feis committee, but I know there are people on the inside ;)
TGC did, well, lets just not talk about it ;) Only the second PC Feis though and first one with a set. Its hard when you place at your 1st PC feis, expectations are higher on down the line.